Explore
6 Westridge Rd

Photo Gallery

Set on nearly three acres overlooking the glittering waters of Otsego Lake, this exceptional Cooperstown compound offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of local history.

Built in 1884 by Dr. Robert McKim and designed by renowned New York City architects Babb, Cook & Willard, the residence stands as a distinguished example of American Shingle Style architecture.

As architectural historian Richard G. Wilson once observed, “The McKim house is one of the best examples I have seen of the Shingle Style country house. It is beautiful. It should be treasured.”

Similar designs can be seen in the Charles Atwater House (New Haven, CT, 1890) and the William Low House (1887), designed by McKim, Mead & White. Today, the property’s stunning position frames panoramic views of Otsego Lake, the iconic Otesaga Hotel (1909), and the Leatherstocking Golf Course.

Distinctive architectural features include a two-story turret, a broad lake-facing porch, a summer sleeping porch, and a screened/storm-windowed porch. Hallmarks of the Shingle Style—such as the continuous cedar shingle exterior, sweeping roof lines, and banded window groupings—enhance the home’s timeless appeal.

Spanning more than 6,600 square feet (approx. 615 sq m), the home has long served as a destination for guests from around the world. (Pictured is Yankee outfielder Bobby Murcer in the kitchen with the owner and her brother)

Operating since 1999 as Bryn Brooke Manor Bed &Breakfast, it has welcomed baseball fans and legendary sports figures alike (Dave Concepcion, Paul Blair, Bobby Murcer, Moose Skowron, Hank Bauer, Buck Martinez,Dan Wilson, Jim Leyland, "The Boys of Summer" author Roger Kahn, and jazz composer Dave Frishberg all have stayed under this roof) —each one adding a new story to the home’s illustrious heritage. Imagine the grand gatherings with Hall of Famers toasting on the porch during induction weekends. It happened here!

Inside, over 70 windows fill the interiors with natural light, highlighting rich finishes of oak, maple, and butternut wood. Every space has been thoughtfully updated with designer-led enhancements, including period lighting, custom wallpapers, bespoke cabinetry, and artisanal woodwork. Elegant fireplaces with beaded moldings anchor the main living areas, while flexible gathering spots—such as the turret library, front porch, and 3-season room—invite relaxation and entertaining year-round. While there are numerous details to captivate your attention, it’s the impressive mill work that catches your attention first. Warm wood tones with simple, yet elegant designs grace  the stunning front entrance door, with its lattice of carved bead work, and the wainscotting along the unusual split staircase delivering guests to the second floor.

At the heart of the home lies a showstopping,  400-square-foot kitchen designed for lively gatherings and culinary creativity. “Enjoy being in the kitchen, especially with the people you love—it truly is the heart of the home,” says the owner. With direct access to multiple porches and a nearby half bath, this space perfectly blends charm and function.

The property offers eight spacious bedrooms, six full baths, and two half baths, including the private caretaker’s suite on the ground floor featuring a separate entrance, bedroom, study, and full bath. All bathrooms have been updated with premium materials and period-appropriate finishes, ensuring both style and comfort.

Recent upgrades include new furnaces, efficient mini-split systems on the main and second floors, a complete electrical overhaul, freshly painted exterior, and a paved driveway. 

Mature gardens provide explosions of color across the warmer months, leaving a glorious palette in the fall and even more graceful winter interest.

Ideally located on Westridge Road, the home sits within walking distance to the Fenimore Art Museum, The Farmers’ Museum, Otsego Lake, and the Otesaga Hotel. The historic village of Cooperstown—with its boutiques, cafés, and the National Baseball Hall of Fame—lies just beyond.

Whether you continue its legacy as a beloved bed and breakfast or reserve it as a private lakeside retreat, 6 Westridge Road is a historic treasure unlike any other in Cooperstown.